Photo of Onion Bagels

United States · The Lower East Side · 39.87° N, 98.73° W

Onion Bagels

Fried onion and poppy pressed into a boiled crust, kept from burning.

Skip to the content below

At a glance.

Onion Bagels comes from United States · The Lower East Side and appears in The Bread Atlas, in the chapter Rolls, Buns & Bagels. It makes 8 bagels, takes about 20 hours, and uses 12 ingredients and 11 steps.

Yield
Makes 8 bagels
Method
Oven 220°C / 425°F
Time
20 hours
Save to Pinterest

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to tick it off.

  • The Dough
  • Fried Onion Topping
  • The Kettle

Method

  1. Cook the onions first, and undercook them on purpose. Warm the oil in a wide pan over medium-low heat, add the sliced onion and salt, and cook 12–15 minutes, stirring, until limp, translucent and no darker than pale straw. They have a second cooking ahead of them in the oven.

  2. Tip the onions into a bowl with their oil — do not drain them dry. That film of oil is a heat buffer: it spreads the oven's heat across each shred instead of letting the exposed edges take it alone. Cool completely, then stir the poppy seed through.

  3. Soak the dried minced onion in 30 g of water for 10 minutes. Mix the flour, salt and yeast, dissolve the malt in the water at 20°C, and bring it together into a firm, dry dough. Knead 10–12 minutes, adding the soaked onion for the last 2 minutes.

  4. Ferment the dough 60 minutes at 24°C, holding a final dough temperature of 24°C, then divide it into 8 pieces of 100 g. Round each one firmly, set them on a lightly oiled tray, and rest 15 minutes covered.

  5. Roll each into a 22 cm rope, wrap it around your hand until the ends overlap, and seal the join by rolling it under your palm. Open the hole to about 4 cm. Cover and rest 20 minutes, then retard 12–18 hours at 4°C.

  6. Next day, float-test one ring in cold water; it should rise within 10 seconds. Bring the kettle to a rolling boil with the malt, and heat the oven to 220°C / 425°F with a stone on the lower-middle shelf — lower than usual, and deliberately far from the top element.

  7. Boil the bagels in batches, 45 seconds a side. Drain each for 5 seconds and press the top face into the onion mixture, then use your fingers to push the shreds down into the surface rather than leaving them perched on it.

  8. Embedding matters as much as adhesion. Onion pressed into the wet crust sits partly below the surface, where the dough's own moisture holds it under 100°C for much of the bake; onion lying loose on top has nothing between it and the oven.

  9. Bake 12 minutes, then look. If the shreds are already deep brown, tent the tray loosely with foil for the remainder. If they are still pale, leave them uncovered. Total time is 18–22 minutes, to an internal 96–98°C.

  10. An alternative that works well for a hot oven: press on only half the onion before baking, and scatter the rest over the bagels at the 12-minute mark, pressing it into the softened crust with the back of a spoon. It finishes cooked but never scorched.

  11. Cool on a rack 30 minutes. Any onion that has darkened past mahogany should be lifted off — one burnt shred is enough to make an entire bagel taste bitter, and the crumb underneath is entirely good.

Cook’s notes

To serve and keep
Cream cheese, or butter and a slab of chopped liver, or egg salad with plenty of pepper — the deli counter's answers, and they hold up. Eat within the day. Onion bagels are the one variety worth keeping in a separate bag: the smell moves into any bread stored beside them.
World map with United States marked

Where it comes from

Onion and poppy on flat dough is one of the oldest habits of Jewish Poland's bakeries, and it arrived in New York intact. The pletzl — Yiddish for a little flat piece, and known on English-speaking counters as the onion board — is a thin, chewy oval strewn with softened onion and poppy seed, sold by weight and eaten the day it was baked. The bialy carries the same idea inward: a soft roll from Białystok with a floury depression rather than a hole, filled with onion and poppy, whose New York survival and Polish disappearance Mimi Sheraton traced in The Bialy Eaters in 2000. The onion bagel is that flavor moved onto a boiled ring, and it belonged to the same Lower East Side bakeries that sold all three from one window. It is worth knowing the relationship, because it explains the topping: onion here is a cooked, softened, oil-slicked preparation of its own, not a sprinkle of dried granules.

All 303 recipes from United States

Onion Bagels: quick answers

How long does Onion Bagels take?

About 20 hours.

How many does this Onion Bagels recipe make?

This recipe makes 8 bagels.

Where does Onion Bagels come from?

Onion and poppy on flat dough is one of the oldest habits of Jewish Poland's bakeries, and it arrived in New York intact. The pletzl — Yiddish for a little flat piece, and known on English-speaking counters as the onion board — is a thin, chewy oval strewn with softened onion and poppy seed, sold by weight and eaten the day it was baked. The bialy carries the same idea inward: a soft roll from Białystok with a floury depression rather than a hole, filled with onion and poppy, whose New York survival and Polish disappearance Mimi Sheraton traced in The Bialy Eaters in 2000. The onion bagel is that flavor moved onto a boiled ring, and it belonged to the same Lower East Side bakeries that sold all three from one window. It is worth knowing the relationship, because it explains the topping: onion here is a cooked, softened, oil-slicked preparation of its own, not a sprinkle of dried granules.