United States · New York, disputed · 39.87° N, 98.73° W
Everything Bagels
Garlic, onion, poppy, sesame and salt, pressed into a wet crust.
At a glance.
Everything Bagels comes from United States · New York, disputed and appears in The Bread Atlas, in the chapter Rolls, Buns & Bagels. It makes 8 bagels, takes about 20 hours, and uses 14 ingredients and 11 steps.
- Yield
- Makes 8 bagels
- Method
- Oven 220°C / 425°F
- Time
- 20 hours
Ingredients
Tap an ingredient to tick it off.
- The Dough
- Everything Seasoning — makes about 100 g
- The Kettle
Method
-
Make the seasoning first. Toast the white sesame in a dry pan over medium heat for 3–4 minutes, until it smells nutty and a few seeds jump, and tip it straight onto a cold plate. Leave the black sesame and poppy raw; they scorch before they toast.
-
Do not toast the garlic and onion. Dried alliums carry sugars that darken well below bread-baking temperature, and pre-toasted granules turn black and acrid in the oven. Combine everything cold in a shallow tray wide enough to take a whole bagel face-down, and shake it level.
-
For the dough, dissolve the malt syrup in the water at 20°C, then mix in the flour, salt and yeast to a firm, dry mass. Knead 10–12 minutes to a smooth, tight dough at a final temperature of 24°C, and ferment 60 minutes at 24°C.
-
Divide into 8 pieces of 100 g, round, and rest 15 minutes. Shape by the poke-and-stretch method if you prefer it to the rope: drive a floured thumb through the center of each ball, then spin the ring on both index fingers until the hole opens to 5 cm.
-
A wide hole matters more here than on a plain bagel. Seasoning has weight, the ring closes as it bakes, and a generous hole is what keeps the finished bagel from sealing into a seeded disc.
-
Cover and rest 20 minutes at room temperature, then retard 12–18 hours at 4°C. Chilling also firms the surface, and a firm surface takes a heavy topping without denting under the pressure of your hand.
-
Heat the oven to 220°C / 425°F with a stone inside, and bring the kettle to a rolling boil with its malt. Float-test one bagel in cold water before you commit the batch.
-
Boil two or three at a time for 45 seconds a side. Lift, drain 5 seconds — no longer — and press the top face down into the seasoning tray, then lift straight up. The window for adhesion is short: gelatinized starch is glue for about a minute, and a dry bagel takes nothing.
-
If a bagel comes out patchy, brush the bare area with the egg white wash and press it back into the tray. Never sprinkle from above; loose seasoning that has not been pressed into a wet surface falls off in the oven and burns on the stone.
-
Bake 18–22 minutes, rotating at 12, until the crust is mahogany and the garlic is pale gold rather than brown. If the alliums are darkening at 14 minutes, drop the oven to 205°C and give it 4 minutes longer.
-
Cool on a rack 30 minutes, seeded side up so the topping is not crushed while it is still soft. Sweep the loose seasoning off the tray into a jar; it keeps three months in the dark and is the honest origin of the whole idea.
Cook’s notes
- To serve and keep
- Everything is the bagel you do not put a strong filling on. Plain cream cheese, or butter, or nothing. Split and toasted, it perfumes an entire kitchen. Keep it in paper for a day at most; the salt in the topping pulls moisture out of the crust and softens it overnight in plastic.
Where it comes from
Two men claim the everything bagel and neither can prove it. David Gussin has said he was a teenager sweeping the seed trays at a bagel shop in Howard Beach, Queens, around 1980, and baked the sweepings onto a batch on a dare. Seth Godin has said he did something similar at a shop near Buffalo in the same era. Both accounts are first-person recollections given decades later, no bakery ledger or menu supports either, and the practice they describe — reusing the mixed seed that collects under a topping station — was ordinary in bakeries long before either man was born. What is documented is the name's spread: everything bagel appears in New York listings through the 1980s, and the blend escaped the bakery entirely when supermarkets began bottling it as a seasoning in the 2010s, after which it turned up on eggs, avocado, fries and crisps. The bagel underneath is the New York formula unchanged. Only the topping is the argument.
Everything Bagels: quick answers
How long does Everything Bagels take?
About 20 hours.
How many does this Everything Bagels recipe make?
This recipe makes 8 bagels.
Where does Everything Bagels come from?
Two men claim the everything bagel and neither can prove it. David Gussin has said he was a teenager sweeping the seed trays at a bagel shop in Howard Beach, Queens, around 1980, and baked the sweepings onto a batch on a dare. Seth Godin has said he did something similar at a shop near Buffalo in the same era. Both accounts are first-person recollections given decades later, no bakery ledger or menu supports either, and the practice they describe — reusing the mixed seed that collects under a topping station — was ordinary in bakeries long before either man was born. What is documented is the name's spread: everything bagel appears in New York listings through the 1980s, and the blend escaped the bakery entirely when supermarkets began bottling it as a seasoning in the 2010s, after which it turned up on eggs, avocado, fries and crisps. The bagel underneath is the New York formula unchanged. Only the topping is the argument.











