Photo of Mushroom Soup

Italy · The Porcini Trade · 43.43° N, 12.37° E

Mushroom Soup

Dark, meaty and barely creamed, built on dried porcini and their soaking liquor.

Skip to the content below

At a glance.

Mushroom Soup comes from Italy · The Porcini Trade and appears in The Soup Atlas, in the chapter Creamy & Pureed Soups. It serves 6, takes about 1 hr 10 min, and uses 17 ingredients and 11 steps.

Yield
Serves 6
Method
Stovetop
Time
1 hr 10 min
Save to Pinterest

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to tick it off.

  • For the porcini broth
  • For the mushrooms
  • To season and finish

Method

  1. Put the dried porcini in a bowl and pour over the hot water. Weigh them down with a saucer and leave them 25 minutes. Water off the boil extracts the aromatics without stewing them; boiling water flattens the smell into something closer to stock cube.

  2. Lift the porcini out by hand, squeeze them over the bowl and chop them roughly. Now decant the liquor slowly into a jug and stop before the last centimeter, where the grit has settled. Porcini are dried with the forest still on them.

  3. Wipe the fresh mushrooms rather than washing them, and tear or slice them thickly. Small pieces give up their water too fast and never get the chance to brown; keep them chunky and let the blender deal with size later.

  4. Set a wide, heavy pan over high heat and add half the mushrooms with no fat at all. They will release water, sputter and go quiet as it evaporates, then begin to squeak against the metal and stick. That squeak is the signal. Repeat with the second batch.

  5. Return all the mushrooms to the pan, add the olive oil and butter and brown them properly over medium-high heat for 8–10 minutes, until they are shrunken, dark at the edges and about a third of their original volume. Salt them only now — salt at the start would have pulled out water you were trying to drive off.

  6. Lift out a generous handful of the browned mushrooms and set them aside for the top of the bowls.

  7. Drop the heat, add the onion, garlic and thyme to the pan and cook for 6–8 minutes until soft. Pour in the sherry and scrape the brown crust off the base with a wooden spoon as it bubbles down to almost nothing.

  8. Add the chopped porcini, the decanted liquor and the stock. Simmer, uncovered, for 25 minutes. The pot should smell of woodland and toast, and the liquid should darken visibly as it reduces.

  9. Blend in batches, filling the jug a third full, venting the lid and covering it with a folded towel. Run it long — 60–90 seconds a batch — until the flecks disappear and the soup turns glossy and opaque.

  10. Return it to the pot over low heat and stir in the soy sauce, which vanishes as a flavor and stays as depth. Season with the salt and the cracked pepper, then add the sherry vinegar off the heat and taste. It should read savory and slightly sharp, not sweet.

  11. Ladle out and top each bowl with the reserved mushrooms, parsley, a thread of olive oil and, if you want it, half a teaspoon of crème fraîche stirred loosely through. Any more dairy than that and you have made a different soup.

Cook’s notes

The technique
Mushrooms taste of meat because they are chemically arranged like it. Their proteins break down as they age and dry, freeing glutamic acid from the chains that bind it, and free glutamate is the molecule the tongue's savory receptor actually detects — the compound Kikunae Ikeda isolated from kelp in 1908 and named umami. A dried porcini can carry several times the free glutamate of a fresh one, which is why 30 g of them outweighs 700 g of fresh in the finished pot. Browning adds a second layer on top, and the soaking liquor holds a third. Throw that liquor away and you have thrown away the soup.
Make ahead
This improves markedly on day two as the porcini keep leaching into the liquid, and it holds four days refrigerated. It freezes cleanly for three months precisely because there is almost no dairy in it to break. Reheat over medium heat, stirring; it thickens overnight, so loosen with stock rather than water. Add the vinegar and any crème fraîche after reheating, never before.
Troubleshooting
Beige and watery — the mushrooms were crowded and steamed instead of browning; work in two batches next time and give them the full ten minutes. Gritty on the tongue — the porcini liquor was poured out to the last drop. Bitter — the pan scorched past brown to black during the dry sauté. Muddy and sweet — too much onion and not enough vinegar at the end.
Variations
A Piedmontese version stirs in cooked rice or barley before blending and leaves it thicker. Polish zupa grzybowa runs the same dried-mushroom broth through with soured cream and noodles. Add a spoonful of white miso in place of soy for a rounder, less salty depth. For a richer bowl, poach a soft egg into each serving and let the yolk do what the cream is not doing.
To serve and keep
Serve it in dark bowls, where its color reads as an asset rather than a fault, with rye toast rubbed with a cut garlic clove. A shaving of Parmesan is welcome, truffle oil is not. Drink a Barbera or a Nebbiolo, or the same dry sherry that went into the pot, cold. Made in full within this recipe — Porcini Broth, Browned Mushroom Garnish. Also listed in the Component Index at the back.
World map with Italy marked

Where it comes from

Porcini cannot be farmed. Boletus edulis lives in partnership with the roots of oak, chestnut, beech and pine, trading sugars for minerals, and no one has managed to make it fruit on a commercial bed — which is why every dried porcini sold has been carried out of a wood by somebody. In the Apennine valleys above Parma this created a genuine economy: the Fungo di Borgotaro was granted protected geographical status by the European Union in 1996, the first Italian mushroom to receive it, and its gathering has been regulated by local permit for decades. Drying was the trade's engine, since fresh boletes go soft and wormy in days while dried ones keep for years and travel anywhere. French kitchens turned wild mushrooms into velouté and folded them into cream; Italian and Alpine cooking more often left them dark and thin, letting the soaking liquor do the work. This soup follows the second habit. The cream of mushroom at recipe 15 is a French velouté with a roux; what you are making here has no flour in it at all.

All 110 recipes from Italy

Mushroom Soup: quick answers

How long does Mushroom Soup take?

About 1 hr 10 min.

How many does this Mushroom Soup recipe make?

This recipe serves 6.

Where does Mushroom Soup come from?

Porcini cannot be farmed. Boletus edulis lives in partnership with the roots of oak, chestnut, beech and pine, trading sugars for minerals, and no one has managed to make it fruit on a commercial bed — which is why every dried porcini sold has been carried out of a wood by somebody. In the Apennine valleys above Parma this created a genuine economy: the Fungo di Borgotaro was granted protected geographical status by the European Union in 1996, the first Italian mushroom to receive it, and its gathering has been regulated by local permit for decades. Drying was the trade's engine, since fresh boletes go soft and wormy in days while dried ones keep for years and travel anywhere. French kitchens turned wild mushrooms into velouté and folded them into cream; Italian and Alpine cooking more often left them dark and thin, letting the soaking liquor do the work. This soup follows the second habit. The cream of mushroom at recipe 15 is a French velouté with a roux; what you are making here has no flour in it at all.