Photo of Beet Soup

Poland & the Baltic · Beet, Horseradish and Dill · 52.13° N, 19.34° E

Beet Soup

Whole-roasted beets blended smooth, sharpened with horseradish and dill.

Skip to the content below

At a glance.

Beet Soup comes from Poland & the Baltic · Beet, Horseradish and Dill and appears in The Soup Atlas, in the chapter Creamy & Pureed Soups. It serves 4, takes about 1 hr 30 min, and uses 19 ingredients and 11 steps.

Yield
Serves 4
Method
Stovetop & Oven
Time
1 hr 30 min
Save to Pinterest

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to tick it off.

  • For the roasted beets
  • For the soup
  • For the horseradish cream
  • To finish

Method

  1. Heat the oven to 200°C (400°F). Sit the beets on a large sheet of foil, trickle over the olive oil and the water, scatter the flaky salt and fold the foil into a sealed parcel. The trapped steam is what cooks them; roasted naked, they go leathery.

  2. Roast for 60–70 minutes, depending on size. They are ready when a thin knife slides to the center and out again with no drag. Open the parcel away from your face — the steam inside is fierce.

  3. Let them cool for 15 minutes, then rub the skins off with a paper towel. They come away in sheets. Wear gloves or work on a board you do not mind marking; beet pigment is a determined dye and it will find your cuffs.

  4. Roasting rather than boiling is the point of this stage. A boiled beet leaks its color and a good part of its sugar into water you then pour away; a foil-wrapped one keeps both, and concentrates them as it loses moisture.

  5. Cut the peeled beets into rough chunks. Melt the butter in a heavy pot over medium-low heat and cook the onion for 8 minutes until soft, then add the garlic and caraway and stir for a minute until the seeds smell of rye bread.

  6. Add the chopped apple and cook for 5 minutes until it begins to collapse. Apple is here for acidity and a little pectin body, not for sweetness, which is why it must be a tart variety.

  7. Add the beets and the stock, bring to a simmer and cook uncovered for 20 minutes so the flavors settle together. The pot will be an alarming magenta; it darkens to garnet once blended.

  8. Blend in batches, a third of a jug at a time, lid vented under a folded towel. Run each batch 90 seconds, then pass it through a fine sieve — beet holds fine fiber that a blender alone leaves behind as a faint grit.

  9. Make the horseradish cream while it blends: stir the grated horseradish, lemon juice and salt into the sour cream and leave it 10 minutes. Grate horseradish at arm's length, and expect it to sting the eyes far more sharply than onion does.

  10. Return the soup to low heat, season with the 1½ teaspoons of salt and the black pepper, then add the vinegar off the heat and taste. Beet is earthy and intensely sweet at once, and acid is the hinge; add it in half-tablespoons until the pot tastes clean rather than like sugared soil.

  11. Ladle into bowls, spoon the horseradish cream into the middle and drag it half through, then scatter dill fronds and trail a little olive oil over the top. Serve hot — this soup is not the chilled one.

Cook’s notes

The technique
Beets are the sweetest common vegetable, running to eight or ten percent sugar, and they carry geosmin, the same earth-smelling compound that gives rain-wet soil and some freshwater fish their character. Sweetness plus earth with nothing else is heavy going, and both problems have the same answer: acid, added off the heat and in stages. Vinegar cuts the sugar, and horseradish adds a volatile pungency that clears the earthiness from the back of the palate. Roast rather than boil, so the sugar concentrates instead of draining away, and sieve after blending, because beet fiber is fine enough to feel and too fine to see.
Make ahead
This is a good keeper: four days refrigerated, three months frozen, and it comes back from both without much loss. The color deepens rather than fades. Roast the beets up to three days ahead and keep them peeled in a sealed box. Make the horseradish cream on the day, since fresh horseradish loses most of its pungency within a few hours of grating. Reheat gently and re-season with vinegar and salt.
Troubleshooting
Sweet and muddy — not enough vinegar; add it half a tablespoon at a time off the heat. Gritty — the purée went unsieved. Pale and washed out — the beets were boiled rather than foil-roasted. Sour cream curdling on contact — the soup was too hot when it went on, so let it drop below a rolling steam and loosen the cream with a spoonful of soup first.
Variations
Add a roasted parsnip or two for a rounder, less sweet pot. Blending in a cooked potato thickens it and mutes the earthiness for anyone who finds beet aggressive. Orange zest and a splash of the juice in place of some of the vinegar makes it brighter and more modern. For a vegan bowl, use olive oil, and whisk the horseradish into thick cashew cream.
To serve and keep
Serve it hot in pale bowls, where the color does its own work, with the cream unstirred so the swirl is visible. Rye bread and salted butter belong beside it. Drink a chilled Zweigelt or a Pinot Noir, or ice-cold vodka in small glasses if the meal is going that way. Made in full within this recipe — Foil-Roasted Beets, Horseradish Cream. Also listed in the Component Index at the back.
World map with Poland marked

Where it comes from

Beta vulgaris began as a leaf crop. The sea beet of the Mediterranean coast was grown for its greens long before anyone bothered with the root, and swollen-rooted forms are only clearly described from the Roman period onward. The plant's second life is industrial and northern: in 1747 the Berlin chemist Andreas Marggraf demonstrated that beet root contained the same sugar as cane, and his student Franz Karl Achard opened the first beet-sugar factory at Cunern in Silesia in 1801. Napoleon, cut off from Caribbean cane by the British blockade, ordered beet acreage planted across France in 1811, and the crop settled permanently into the fields of Poland, Germany and the Baltic. Cooking followed the farming. Polish kitchens pair beet with horseradish in ćwikła, the grated relish eaten at Easter, and dill runs through the whole region's cooking. What follows takes that pairing into a smooth hot soup. It is not borscht, which is at recipe 90 and is built on cabbage, stock and a sour edge, and it is not the chilled chłodnik at 82.

All 3 recipes from Poland

Beet Soup: quick answers

How long does Beet Soup take?

About 1 hr 30 min.

How many does this Beet Soup recipe make?

This recipe serves 4.

Where does Beet Soup come from?

Beta vulgaris began as a leaf crop. The sea beet of the Mediterranean coast was grown for its greens long before anyone bothered with the root, and swollen-rooted forms are only clearly described from the Roman period onward. The plant's second life is industrial and northern: in 1747 the Berlin chemist Andreas Marggraf demonstrated that beet root contained the same sugar as cane, and his student Franz Karl Achard opened the first beet-sugar factory at Cunern in Silesia in 1801. Napoleon, cut off from Caribbean cane by the British blockade, ordered beet acreage planted across France in 1811, and the crop settled permanently into the fields of Poland, Germany and the Baltic. Cooking followed the farming. Polish kitchens pair beet with horseradish in ćwikła, the grated relish eaten at Easter, and dill runs through the whole region's cooking. What follows takes that pairing into a smooth hot soup. It is not borscht, which is at recipe 90 and is built on cabbage, stock and a sour edge, and it is not the chilled chłodnik at 82.