France · Potage Parmentier · 46.56° N, 2.35° E
Potato Leek Soup
Sweet leeks and floury potato, crushed rather than blended, eaten hot.
At a glance.
Potato Leek Soup comes from France · Potage Parmentier and appears in The Soup Atlas, in the chapter Classic & Everyday Soups. It serves 6, takes about 1 hr 10 min, and uses 19 ingredients and 11 steps.
- Yield
- Serves 6
- Method
- Stovetop
- Time
- 1 hr 10 min
Ingredients
Tap an ingredient to tick it off.
- For the leek-top stock
- For the soup
- For the crisped leek greens
- To finish
Method
-
Trim the leeks and keep the dark green tops. Split every part lengthways and fan the layers under cold running water — grit works its way down between the sheaths and a single missed pocket puts sand through the whole pot.
-
Put the washed green tops in a pan with the onion, celery, parsley stalks, bay and white peppercorns, cover with the cold water and simmer gently for 30 minutes. Strain it and discard the solids. You will have a pale, sweet, faintly oniony stock that costs you nothing.
-
Slice the white and pale green leek 5 mm thick. Melt the butter in a heavy pot over low heat, add the leeks and the teaspoon of salt, cover, and sweat for 15 minutes, stirring twice.
-
They are ready when they have gone limp and glassy and smell sweet, with no browning anywhere. Color here brings a nutty, allium-forward note that overrides the delicacy this soup is built on, and once it is there it cannot be taken out.
-
Add the potato chunks, the bay leaves and 1.2 liters of the strained stock — enough to cover by 2 cm, no more. Drowning the potato gives you a thin soup that then has to be reduced, which overcooks the leek.
-
Bring it to a gentle simmer and cook uncovered for 20–25 minutes, until the potato gives way completely when pressed against the side of the pot with a spoon and the edges have begun to fray into the liquid.
-
While it simmers, crisp the leek threads. Heat the oil to 150°C (300°F), add the dried threads and fry for 2–3 minutes, stirring, until they stop bubbling and turn pale gold. Lift them onto paper immediately — they scorch in seconds and burnt leek is bitter.
-
Remove the bay. Now crush rather than blend: use a masher or the back of a ladle and work the pot until about half the potato has broken down and the rest remains in soft, recognizable pieces. This is a rustic soup and the texture is the point of it.
-
Never put potato through a high-speed blender. The blades rupture the starch granules and release long chains of amylose and amylopectin that turn the soup into wallpaper paste within seconds. A food mill or a ricer is the only mechanical route that is safe.
-
Stir in the cream over low heat and let it warm through without simmering. Season with salt in stages and with white pepper — black pepper works as well but leaves dark specks through a pale soup, which is a matter of looks rather than taste.
-
Take the pot off the heat and beat in the cold butter cube by cube, which gives gloss and a rounder mouthfeel. Ladle out, scatter the chives and the crisped leek threads, and serve hot.
Cook’s notes
- The technique
- Potato starch is the whole risk and the whole reward. Heated in liquid, the granules absorb water and swell until they burst, and the released amylose thickens the soup naturally — which is why this needs no flour and no roux. Break those swollen granules mechanically at high speed, though, and you release far more long-chain starch than the liquid can hold in suspension, and the result is a gluey, elastic texture no amount of stock will thin. Crush by hand, or use a food mill. Choose floury potatoes for a soup you intend to crush and waxy ones only if you want the pieces to stay whole.
- Make ahead
- It keeps three days refrigerated and thickens noticeably as it stands; loosen it with stock rather than water when reheating, over low heat and stirring. Freezing is not recommended — potato cells rupture on thawing and the texture turns grainy and watery. The stock and the sweated leeks can both be done a day ahead. Crisp the leek threads within a few hours of serving.
- Troubleshooting
- Gluey and elastic — it went in a blender; there is no recovery, so serve it as a purée and crush by hand next time. Grainy and thin — waxy potatoes were used, which never break down. Sandy — the leeks were not fanned open under water. Tastes of nothing much — under-salted; pale, starchy soups need noticeably more salt than colored ones to read as seasoned.
- Variations
- Potage bonne femme adds carrot to the leek and a heavier hand with butter. A Welsh cawl cennin uses lamb stock in place of the vegetable one and holds the cream. For a soup without dairy, sweat the leeks in good olive oil and finish with more oil and a squeeze of lemon, which gives brightness where the cream would have given weight.
- To serve and keep
- Serve hot in warm bowls with a spoon of cream stirred to a spiral on top if you like the look. Good bread and salted butter alongside, or a slice of Gruyère toasted under the grill. Drink a dry Chenin Blanc, or a Breton cider, which suits the leek better than most wine does. Made in full within this recipe — Leek-Top Stock, Crisped Leek Greens. Also listed in the Component Index at the back.
Where it comes from
Antoine-Augustin Parmentier was a military pharmacist who survived several spells as a Prussian prisoner during the Seven Years' War on a diet of potatoes, a crop the French then grew for livestock and suspected of causing leprosy. He spent the rest of his life arguing otherwise. The Paris Faculty of Medicine declared the potato fit for human consumption in 1772, largely on his evidence; he served potato dinners to Franklin and Lavoisier, presented Louis XVI with potato flowers, and is said to have posted armed guards around a field at Les Sablons by day and withdrawn them at night so that locals would steal the crop they had been ignoring. That last story is repeated in every account and documented in none, so hold it loosely. His name is now attached to a whole family of potato dishes, including this one — potage parmentier, the plainest and among the best. It belongs on the stove in winter, eaten hot and rough. Chilled, blended silky and passed through a fine sieve, it becomes Vichyssoise, which is recipe 74 and a different dish with different rules.
Potato Leek Soup: quick answers
How long does Potato Leek Soup take?
About 1 hr 10 min.
How many does this Potato Leek Soup recipe make?
This recipe serves 6.
Where does Potato Leek Soup come from?
Antoine-Augustin Parmentier was a military pharmacist who survived several spells as a Prussian prisoner during the Seven Years' War on a diet of potatoes, a crop the French then grew for livestock and suspected of causing leprosy. He spent the rest of his life arguing otherwise. The Paris Faculty of Medicine declared the potato fit for human consumption in 1772, largely on his evidence; he served potato dinners to Franklin and Lavoisier, presented Louis XVI with potato flowers, and is said to have posted armed guards around a field at Les Sablons by day and withdrawn them at night so that locals would steal the crop they had been ignoring. That last story is repeated in every account and documented in none, so hold it loosely. His name is now attached to a whole family of potato dishes, including this one — potage parmentier, the plainest and among the best. It belongs on the stove in winter, eaten hot and rough. Chilled, blended silky and passed through a fine sieve, it becomes Vichyssoise, which is recipe 74 and a different dish with different rules.











