Photo of Custard Pie

United States · 39.87° N, 98.73° W

Custard Pie

The plain baked custard pie of American home cooking: scalded milk, whole eggs, and a broad drift of nutmeg over the top.

Skip to the content below

At a glance.

Custard Pie comes from United States and appears in The Pie Atlas, in the chapter Cream & Custard Pies. It serves 8, bakes at 350°F (175°C) for 40–45 minutes, and uses 10 ingredients and 8 steps.

Yield
Serves 8
Method
Oven
Oven
350°F / 175°C
Bake
40–45 minutes
Save to Pinterest

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to tick it off.

Method

  1. Roll the pastry to 1/8 inch (3 mm), line the plate, crimp a tall rim, and freeze 30 minutes; blind-bake at 375°F (190°C) for 20 minutes with weights and 10 without.

  2. Brush the hot shell inside and out with the beaten egg white and return it to the oven for 3 minutes to set a seal. With a filling this liquid, that seal is the difference between crisp pastry and a soaked floor.

  3. Heat the milk and cream to 180°F (82°C), until a skin begins to form at the edge of the pan, then let it stand 5 minutes off the heat.

  4. Whisk the whole eggs, yolks, sugar and salt together only until combined. Beating in air makes a custard rise, crack and then sink like a failed soufflé.

  5. Temper by pouring the hot dairy into the eggs in a slow thread while stirring, then strain the mixture twice through a fine sieve and skim off every bubble with a spoon.

  6. Set the pastry shell on a pulled-out oven rack, pour the custard in to within 1/4 inch (6 mm) of the rim, and grate the nutmeg over the surface before sliding the rack back in.

  7. Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 40 to 45 minutes. Pull it when a probe at the midpoint between edge and center reads 170°F (77°C) and a 2 inch (5 cm) circle at the middle still shivers.

  8. Cool 2 hours on a rack, then refrigerate at least 3 hours. Custard pie is at its best on the day it is made and is undrinkable in texture after three.

Cook’s notes

Good to know
The ratio here is one whole egg to roughly half a cup of dairy, which is the classic proportion for a custard that slices cleanly without turning rubbery. Above 180°F (82°C) the coagulated protein network contracts and squeezes out water, which is exactly what curdling is, and why the pie leaves the oven while its center is still loose.
World map with United States marked

Where it comes from

The word custard descends from the Old French croustade, meaning a crust — the name originally belonged to the pastry case and only later migrated to the filling inside it. Medieval English crustades were open pies of meat or fruit bound with egg and milk, and the sweet version outlived the savory one. It is one of the oldest continuously baked pies in the language.

All 303 recipes from United States

Custard Pie: quick answers

How long does Custard Pie take to bake?

Custard Pie bakes at 350°F (175°C) for 40–45 minutes. Use the visual cues in the method as well as the clock.

How many does this Custard Pie recipe make?

This recipe serves 8.

Where does Custard Pie come from?

The word custard descends from the Old French croustade, meaning a crust — the name originally belonged to the pastry case and only later migrated to the filling inside it. Medieval English crustades were open pies of meat or fruit bound with egg and milk, and the sweet version outlived the savory one. It is one of the oldest continuously baked pies in the language.

What is the secret to a good Custard Pie?

Pour the custard into the shell after the pie is already on the oven rack — carrying a brimming pie across the kitchen ends one way.