Photo of Coconut Cream Pie

United States · 39.87° N, 98.73° W

Coconut Cream Pie

A pastry cream built on coconut milk rather than dairy alone, with toasted shreds folded through the body and scattered over the crown.

Skip to the content below

At a glance.

Coconut Cream Pie comes from United States and appears in The Pie Atlas, in the chapter Cream & Custard Pies. It serves 8, takes about 4 hours, and uses 12 ingredients and 8 steps.

Yield
Serves 8
Method
Blind-baked shell
Time
4 hours
Save to Pinterest

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to tick it off.

Method

  1. Spread the shredded coconut on a sheet and toast at 350°F (175°C) for 5 to 7 minutes, stirring twice, until two-thirds of it is pale gold. Raw shreds taste of nothing and go slimy in a wet filling.

  2. Shake the can of coconut milk hard before opening, or scoop out the solid cap and the water together and whisk them smooth. Separated coconut milk will give you a greasy custard.

  3. Combine the whole milk, coconut milk, half the sugar and the salt in a saucepan and heat until wisps of steam appear at the edge.

  4. Whisk the remaining sugar with the cornstarch and yolks, temper with the hot liquid, then cook the whole mixture over medium heat until it boils thickly for a full minute.

  5. Coconut milk carries more fat and less protein than dairy, so this custard needs a little extra cornstarch — a third of a cup — to reach the same firmness as a milk-based one.

  6. Take it off the heat and stir in the butter, vanilla and 1 cup (80 g) of the toasted coconut, then cool to lukewarm, stirring now and then to keep the shreds suspended rather than sunk.

  7. Scrape the filling into the shell, level it, lay plastic directly on the surface, and refrigerate for at least 4 hours until set right through.

  8. Whip the cream with the confectioners' sugar to firm peaks, swirl it over the pie, and finish with the remaining toasted coconut immediately before serving so it stays crisp.

Cook’s notes

Good to know
Coconut fat is largely saturated and solid below about 76°F (24°C), so a coconut custard firms noticeably in the refrigerator and softens fast on a warm plate. Toasting the shreds also drives off moisture, which keeps them from leaching water into the set cream.
World map with United States marked

Where it comes from

Packaged shredded coconut is an American invention of the 1890s: a Philadelphia flour miller named Franklin Baker took a shipload of coconuts as payment from a Cuban customer, found no market for whole nuts, and began drying and shredding the meat instead. Cheap sweetened coconut in a box put coconut cake and coconut pie into ordinary kitchens within a generation. Before that, every recipe began with cracking a nut.

All 303 recipes from United States

Coconut Cream Pie: quick answers

How long does Coconut Cream Pie take?

About 4 hours.

How many does this Coconut Cream Pie recipe make?

This recipe serves 8.

Where does Coconut Cream Pie come from?

Packaged shredded coconut is an American invention of the 1890s: a Philadelphia flour miller named Franklin Baker took a shipload of coconuts as payment from a Cuban customer, found no market for whole nuts, and began drying and shredding the meat instead. Cheap sweetened coconut in a box put coconut cake and coconut pie into ordinary kitchens within a generation. Before that, every recipe began with cracking a nut.

What is the secret to a good Coconut Cream Pie?

Hold back a handful of untoasted coconut and fold it in with the toasted — the two textures together read as fresher than either alone.