Photo of Pumpkin Pie

United States · 39.87° N, 98.73° W

Pumpkin Pie

Spiced pumpkin custard cooked down in a pan before it is mixed, which concentrates the flavor and removes the water that makes most versions taste thin.

Skip to the content below

At a glance.

Pumpkin Pie comes from United States and appears in The Pie Atlas, in the chapter Cream & Custard Pies. It serves 8, takes about 55 minutes, and uses 12 ingredients and 8 steps.

Yield
Serves 8
Method
Oven 425°F then 350°F
Bake
55 minutes
Save to Pinterest

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to tick it off.

Method

  1. Line the plate, crimp high, freeze 30 minutes, then blind-bake at 375°F (190°C) for 20 minutes under weights and 12 minutes uncovered until the base is fully colored.

  2. Meanwhile cook the pumpkin purée with the brown sugar, salt and all the spices in a wide saucepan over medium heat for 8 to 10 minutes, stirring constantly.

  3. The purée will spit and darken and shrink to about three-quarters of its volume. You are boiling off water and toasting the spices in the sugar, and it is the single biggest improvement you can make to this pie.

  4. Whisk in the cream to loosen the hot purée, then take the pan off the heat and let it cool for 5 minutes so the eggs will not scramble.

  5. Beat in the whole eggs, yolks and rum, then pass the mixture through a sieve for a texture that is properly silken rather than fibrous.

  6. Pour the warm filling into the warm shell. A warm filling shortens the bake, and a shorter bake is how you avoid the crack that runs across the middle of an overcooked pumpkin pie.

  7. Bake at 425°F (220°C) for 15 minutes to set the outer edge fast, then drop to 350°F (175°C) for 40 minutes, until the center reads 175°F (79°C).

  8. Cool 3 hours at room temperature, then refrigerate uncovered for 2 hours before slicing. It keeps 4 days and is better on the second day.

Cook’s notes

Good to know
Canned pumpkin is roughly 90 percent water, and unreduced it dilutes both the spice and the custard, which is why so many pumpkin pies taste of nothing but cinnamon. Cracks form when the edges overcook while the center catches up, so the two-stage bake and the head start from a warm filling are structural, not cosmetic.
World map with United States marked

Where it comes from

Amelia Simmons's American Cookery of 1796, the first cookbook written by an American, includes two recipes for pompkin pudding baked in a crust, both spiced with mace, nutmeg and ginger. Earlier colonists had done something rougher, filling a hollowed pumpkin with milk, spice and honey and setting it directly in the embers. Squash was one of the crops that carried New England through its first winters, and the pie is a memorial to that.

All 303 recipes from United States

Pumpkin Pie: quick answers

How long does Pumpkin Pie take?

About 55 minutes.

How many does this Pumpkin Pie recipe make?

This recipe serves 8.

Where does Pumpkin Pie come from?

Amelia Simmons's American Cookery of 1796, the first cookbook written by an American, includes two recipes for pompkin pudding baked in a crust, both spiced with mace, nutmeg and ginger. Earlier colonists had done something rougher, filling a hollowed pumpkin with milk, spice and honey and setting it directly in the embers. Squash was one of the crops that carried New England through its first winters, and the pie is a memorial to that.

What is the secret to a good Pumpkin Pie?

Ignore the clean-knife test entirely — by the time a blade comes out clean from the center, the pie is five minutes overdone.