United States (Indiana) · 39.77° N, 86.16° W
Sugar Cream Pie
A pale, quivering cream filling cooked on the stove with nothing but sugar, cream, and cornstarch, dusted with nutmeg and browned under a hot oven.
At a glance.
Sugar Cream Pie comes from United States (Indiana) and appears in The Pie Atlas, in the chapter Nut, Chocolate & Sweet Pies. It serves 8, takes about 4 hours, and uses 10 ingredients and 8 steps.
- Yield
- Serves 8
- Method
- Blind-baked shell
- Time
- 4 hours
Ingredients
Tap an ingredient to tick it off.
Method
-
Blind-bake the shell fully at 375°F (190°C), 20 minutes under weights and 12 minutes uncovered, until it is evenly golden through the base. There is no egg in this filling to firm a soggy crust, so the shell must be finished before it is filled.
-
Whisk the granulated sugar, cornstarch, and salt together in a heavy saucepan while still dry. Cornstarch stirred into liquid seizes into lumps that no whisk will break.
-
Pour in the cream and milk in a thin stream, whisking constantly, until the mixture is entirely smooth and no starch is settled in the corners of the pan.
-
Cook over medium heat, stirring with a flat-ended spatula so nothing catches, for 8 to 10 minutes, until it thickens abruptly and coats the back of the spatula.
-
Bring it to a full boil and hold it there, stirring, for 90 seconds. Cornstarch does not reach its maximum thickening until it boils, and an unboiled starch cream thins back out overnight.
-
Take the pan off the heat and beat in the butter and vanilla. Adding fat after the boil keeps it from interfering with the starch as it swells.
-
Pour the hot filling into the baked shell, level it, dust generously with the nutmeg and demerara, and slide it under a broiler for 60 to 90 seconds until the surface blisters and freckles brown. Watch it continuously.
-
Cool to room temperature, then refrigerate 4 hours until set firm. Serve cold; it keeps 3 days, covered loosely so condensation does not pool on the surface.
Cook’s notes
- Good to know
- This is one of the few American pies with no eggs at all — the set comes entirely from gelatinized cornstarch, which is why the texture is smooth and slightly slippery rather than the softer set of a custard. Starch-thickened creams also survive freezing badly, because the starch network weeps water when it thaws.
Where it comes from
Sugar cream pie is Indiana's unofficial state pie — the title is a matter of long custom rather than statute — and the state has a good claim on it: Shaker and Quaker settlers along the National Road were baking it by the mid-nineteenth century. It is sometimes called finger pie, from the practice of stirring the filling in the shell with a finger because a spoon would tear the raw crust.
Sugar Cream Pie: quick answers
How long does Sugar Cream Pie take?
About 4 hours.
How many does this Sugar Cream Pie recipe make?
This recipe serves 8.
Where does Sugar Cream Pie come from?
Sugar cream pie is Indiana's unofficial state pie — the title is a matter of long custom rather than statute — and the state has a good claim on it: Shaker and Quaker settlers along the National Road were baking it by the mid-nineteenth century. It is sometimes called finger pie, from the practice of stirring the filling in the shell with a finger because a spoon would tear the raw crust.
What is the secret to a good Sugar Cream Pie?
Press a round of buttered parchment onto the surface if you are not broiling it, or you will get a rubbery skin instead of a smooth top.











