Photo of Sugar Cream Pie

United States (Indiana) · 39.77° N, 86.16° W

Sugar Cream Pie

A pale, quivering cream filling cooked on the stove with nothing but sugar, cream, and cornstarch, dusted with nutmeg and browned under a hot oven.

Skip to the content below

At a glance.

Sugar Cream Pie comes from United States (Indiana) and appears in The Pie Atlas, in the chapter Nut, Chocolate & Sweet Pies. It serves 8, takes about 4 hours, and uses 10 ingredients and 8 steps.

Yield
Serves 8
Method
Blind-baked shell
Time
4 hours
Save to Pinterest

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to tick it off.

Method

  1. Blind-bake the shell fully at 375°F (190°C), 20 minutes under weights and 12 minutes uncovered, until it is evenly golden through the base. There is no egg in this filling to firm a soggy crust, so the shell must be finished before it is filled.

  2. Whisk the granulated sugar, cornstarch, and salt together in a heavy saucepan while still dry. Cornstarch stirred into liquid seizes into lumps that no whisk will break.

  3. Pour in the cream and milk in a thin stream, whisking constantly, until the mixture is entirely smooth and no starch is settled in the corners of the pan.

  4. Cook over medium heat, stirring with a flat-ended spatula so nothing catches, for 8 to 10 minutes, until it thickens abruptly and coats the back of the spatula.

  5. Bring it to a full boil and hold it there, stirring, for 90 seconds. Cornstarch does not reach its maximum thickening until it boils, and an unboiled starch cream thins back out overnight.

  6. Take the pan off the heat and beat in the butter and vanilla. Adding fat after the boil keeps it from interfering with the starch as it swells.

  7. Pour the hot filling into the baked shell, level it, dust generously with the nutmeg and demerara, and slide it under a broiler for 60 to 90 seconds until the surface blisters and freckles brown. Watch it continuously.

  8. Cool to room temperature, then refrigerate 4 hours until set firm. Serve cold; it keeps 3 days, covered loosely so condensation does not pool on the surface.

Cook’s notes

Good to know
This is one of the few American pies with no eggs at all — the set comes entirely from gelatinized cornstarch, which is why the texture is smooth and slightly slippery rather than the softer set of a custard. Starch-thickened creams also survive freezing badly, because the starch network weeps water when it thaws.
World map with Indiana marked

Where it comes from

Sugar cream pie is Indiana's unofficial state pie — the title is a matter of long custom rather than statute — and the state has a good claim on it: Shaker and Quaker settlers along the National Road were baking it by the mid-nineteenth century. It is sometimes called finger pie, from the practice of stirring the filling in the shell with a finger because a spoon would tear the raw crust.

All 303 recipes from United States

Sugar Cream Pie: quick answers

How long does Sugar Cream Pie take?

About 4 hours.

How many does this Sugar Cream Pie recipe make?

This recipe serves 8.

Where does Sugar Cream Pie come from?

Sugar cream pie is Indiana's unofficial state pie — the title is a matter of long custom rather than statute — and the state has a good claim on it: Shaker and Quaker settlers along the National Road were baking it by the mid-nineteenth century. It is sometimes called finger pie, from the practice of stirring the filling in the shell with a finger because a spoon would tear the raw crust.

What is the secret to a good Sugar Cream Pie?

Press a round of buttered parchment onto the surface if you are not broiling it, or you will get a rubbery skin instead of a smooth top.