United States (Pennsylvania Dutch) · 40.04° N, 76.31° W
Shoofly Pie
The wet-bottom kind: a dark sticky molasses layer beneath a soft crumb cake, with buttery streusel scattered over the top.
At a glance.
Shoofly Pie comes from United States (Pennsylvania Dutch) and appears in The Pie Atlas, in the chapter Nut, Chocolate & Sweet Pies. It serves 8, bakes at 350°F (175°C) for 40 minutes, and uses 11 ingredients and 8 steps.
- Yield
- Serves 8
- Method
- Oven
- Oven
- 350°F / 175°C
- Bake
- 40 minutes
Ingredients
Tap an ingredient to tick it off.
Method
-
Line the plate with pastry rolled to 1/8 inch (3 mm), crimp a tall rim to hold the volume, and chill 30 minutes. This shell is not blind-baked; the molasses layer bakes onto raw pastry and seals it.
-
Rub the flour, brown sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, salt, and cold butter between your fingertips until the mixture holds together in pea-sized clumps when squeezed. Stop while it is still loose and pebbly.
-
Set aside 1 cup (about 130 g) of the crumb for the top and reserve it in the refrigerator, so the pieces stay distinct rather than melting into a sheet.
-
Stir the baking soda into the boiling water, then whisk in the molasses. The soda neutralizes some of the molasses acid and gives off carbon dioxide, which is the only lift this pie has.
-
Cool the molasses mixture to lukewarm and whisk in the beaten egg. Pouring boiling liquid onto egg would set it into threads.
-
Stir the remaining crumb into the molasses liquid until barely combined, pour into the shell, and scatter the reserved cold crumb evenly over the surface.
-
Bake at 350°F (175°C) on the middle shelf for 40 minutes. The top should be firm and dry to a light touch while the bottom half stays molten — a skewer will come out clean at the top and tacky at the base, and that is the wet bottom working.
-
Cool at least 2 hours so the molasses layer thickens from syrup into a set gel. It keeps 4 days under a cloth and is traditionally eaten at breakfast with black coffee.
Cook’s notes
- Good to know
- Molasses is the syrup left after sugar crystals are spun out of cane juice; each successive boiling makes it darker, more mineral, and more bitter, which is why blackstrap ruins this pie. Its acidity is the reason baking soda works here without any baking powder.
Where it comes from
Shoofly pie is Pennsylvania Dutch, built from molasses and flour in a farmhouse economy where both kept through winter and fruit did not. There are two schools and they are not interchangeable — the dry-bottom bakes the molasses fully into the crumb and slices like coffee cake, while the wet-bottom, made here, deliberately leaves a gooey molasses stratum at the base. The name is usually explained by flies drawn to open molasses, though a molasses brand called Shoofly circulated in the same region and may have worked the other way around.
All 303 recipes from United States
All 2 recipes from Netherlands
Shoofly Pie: quick answers
How long does Shoofly Pie take to bake?
Shoofly Pie bakes at 350°F (175°C) for 40 minutes. Use the visual cues in the method as well as the clock.
How many does this Shoofly Pie recipe make?
This recipe serves 8.
Where does Shoofly Pie come from?
Shoofly pie is Pennsylvania Dutch, built from molasses and flour in a farmhouse economy where both kept through winter and fruit did not. There are two schools and they are not interchangeable — the dry-bottom bakes the molasses fully into the crumb and slices like coffee cake, while the wet-bottom, made here, deliberately leaves a gooey molasses stratum at the base. The name is usually explained by flies drawn to open molasses, though a molasses brand called Shoofly circulated in the same region and may have worked the other way around.
What is the secret to a good Shoofly Pie?
Keep the reserved crumb in the refrigerator until the moment it is scattered — warm crumb sinks straight through the batter and you lose the top layer entirely.











