Photo of Coconut Custard Pie

United States · 39.87° N, 98.73° W

Coconut Custard Pie

The baked cousin of coconut cream: one custard poured over shredded coconut, which rises during the bake and toasts into a lid of its own.

Skip to the content below

At a glance.

Coconut Custard Pie comes from United States and appears in The Pie Atlas, in the chapter Cream & Custard Pies. It serves 8, bakes at 350°F (175°C) for 45 minutes, and uses 12 ingredients and 8 steps.

Yield
Serves 8
Method
Oven
Oven
350°F / 175°C
Bake
45 minutes
Save to Pinterest

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to tick it off.

Method

  1. Line the plate with pastry at 1/8 inch (3 mm), freeze it for 30 minutes, then blind-bake at 375°F (190°C) for 20 minutes weighted and 10 minutes uncovered.

  2. Seal the hot shell with the beaten egg white and give it 3 minutes back in the oven, because this filling is thinner at the moment of pouring than any other in the chapter.

  3. Heat the whole milk and coconut milk together with half the sugar until steam rises, then remove from the heat and stir in the shredded coconut.

  4. Let it steep 15 minutes. Dry shreds dropped straight into a custard draw liquid out of it as they bake and leave the set grainy and short of moisture.

  5. Whisk the eggs, yolk, remaining sugar and salt only to combine, without raising foam, then stir in the warm coconut milk, the melted butter and both extracts.

  6. Pour the mixture into the shell; the hydrated coconut will float to the top within a minute and settle into an even layer, which is exactly what you want.

  7. Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 45 minutes on a low rack. The coconut cap will toast to a light brown while the custard beneath reaches 170°F (77°C) with a 2 inch (5 cm) wobble.

  8. Cool 2 hours, then chill 3 hours before slicing. It holds 3 days refrigerated, and the coconut layer softens gradually into the custard as it sits.

Cook’s notes

Good to know
Shredded coconut floats because it is less dense than the liquid around it and because it has absorbed enough of that liquid to swell, so it forms an insulating raft that browns while shielding the custard from the oven's direct heat. The coconut fiber also binds free water, which is why this pie needs slightly less egg per cup of dairy than a plain custard.
World map with United States marked

Where it comes from

Where a cream pie is stirred on the stove and spooned into a finished shell, a custard pie is mixed cold and set in the oven, and coconut is one of the few fillings that works well both ways. The distinction was blurred in the 1970s by so-called impossible pies, batters that separated in the oven into a custard layer with a self-forming crust of coconut and flour beneath. Those novelties are descendants of this pie, not the other way round.

All 303 recipes from United States

Coconut Custard Pie: quick answers

How long does Coconut Custard Pie take to bake?

Coconut Custard Pie bakes at 350°F (175°C) for 45 minutes. Use the visual cues in the method as well as the clock.

How many does this Coconut Custard Pie recipe make?

This recipe serves 8.

Where does Coconut Custard Pie come from?

Where a cream pie is stirred on the stove and spooned into a finished shell, a custard pie is mixed cold and set in the oven, and coconut is one of the few fillings that works well both ways. The distinction was blurred in the 1970s by so-called impossible pies, batters that separated in the oven into a custard layer with a self-forming crust of coconut and flour beneath. Those novelties are descendants of this pie, not the other way round.

What is the secret to a good Coconut Custard Pie?

Sweetened flaked coconut can be substituted, but cut the sugar to half a cup or the filling will be cloying and slow to set.