American South · 33.52° N, 86.80° W
Buttermilk Pie
A pale, tangy custard with a thin crackled sugar top, built from four things almost every farmhouse kitchen had on the worst day of the year.
At a glance.
Buttermilk Pie comes from American South and appears in The Pie Atlas, in the chapter Cream & Custard Pies. It serves 8, bakes at 350°F (175°C) for 45 minutes, and uses 11 ingredients and 8 steps.
- Yield
- Serves 8
- Method
- Oven
- Oven
- 350°F / 175°C
- Bake
- 45 minutes
Ingredients
Tap an ingredient to tick it off.
Method
-
Roll and line the plate, crimp a decorative rim, and freeze it 30 minutes before blind-baking at 375°F (190°C) for 20 minutes with weights and 8 minutes without.
-
Whisk the sugar, flour and salt together, then beat in the melted butter until the mixture looks like wet sand and holds together on the whisk.
-
Add the eggs one at a time, beating only until each disappears. This filling wants to be homogeneous, not aerated, because trapped air rises in the oven and leaves a hollow beneath the crust.
-
Stir in the buttermilk, vanilla, lemon juice and zest. The mixture will look alarmingly thin and slightly curdled, which is correct and will not persist.
-
The 3 tablespoons of flour are doing two jobs: thickening and insurance. Starch granules physically separate the milk proteins and stop the acid in the buttermilk from pulling them into visible curds.
-
Pour into the shell, grate the nutmeg across the surface, and set the pie on a heavy sheet in the lower third of a 350°F (175°C) oven.
-
Bake 45 minutes. The top will rise into a thin golden lid that cracks slightly, the edges will be firm, and the middle will still wobble across a 2 inch (5 cm) circle at 170°F (77°C).
-
Cool completely, 4 hours, before cutting. It settles into a denser, silkier texture overnight in the refrigerator and keeps 4 days.
Cook’s notes
- Good to know
- Acid lowers the temperature at which egg proteins coagulate, so a buttermilk custard sets earlier and softer than a plain one and is easy to overbake by five minutes. The sugar works in the opposite direction, raising the setting point, which is why this pie survives a moderate oven at all with a cup and a half of it dissolved inside.
Where it comes from
Buttermilk pie is a churn-day pie. Before butter was made in factories, any household that churned was left with a quantity of thin sour liquid, and Southern cooks baked it into custard rather than pour it away; the recipe turns up under a dozen near-identical names in nineteenth-century community cookbooks from Tennessee to Texas. What the carton sells today is cultured skim milk, rather more acidic than the original and every bit as good in a pie.
Buttermilk Pie: quick answers
How long does Buttermilk Pie take to bake?
Buttermilk Pie bakes at 350°F (175°C) for 45 minutes. Use the visual cues in the method as well as the clock.
How many does this Buttermilk Pie recipe make?
This recipe serves 8.
Where does Buttermilk Pie come from?
Buttermilk pie is a churn-day pie. Before butter was made in factories, any household that churned was left with a quantity of thin sour liquid, and Southern cooks baked it into custard rather than pour it away; the recipe turns up under a dozen near-identical names in nineteenth-century community cookbooks from Tennessee to Texas. What the carton sells today is cultured skim milk, rather more acidic than the original and every bit as good in a pie.
What is the secret to a good Buttermilk Pie?
If you have no buttermilk, sour a cup of whole milk with a tablespoon of lemon juice for 10 minutes — thin yogurt is too thick and will bake heavy.











