Photo of Cream of Tomato

The Soup Atlas

Cream of Tomato

The classical route: a blond roux carries the milk, and nothing splits.

Skip to the content below

At a glance.

Cream of Tomato is a recipe from The Soup Atlas, in the chapter Classic & Everyday Soups. It serves 4, takes about 55 minutes, and uses 20 ingredients and 11 steps.

Yield
Serves 4
Method
Stovetop
Time
55 minutes
Save to Pinterest

Ingredients

Tap an ingredient to tick it off.

  • For the tomato base
  • For the blond roux velouté
  • To season
  • To finish

Method

  1. Warm the milk with the clove-studded onion and its bay leaf until it steams, then take it off the heat and let it infuse for 20 minutes. Lift out the onion. This is the classical infusion and it costs you nothing but patience.

  2. Melt the 30 g of butter in a heavy pan, add the chopped onion and celery and cook gently for 10 minutes until soft and translucent. Add the garlic for a minute, then the tomato paste, and cook it out for 2–3 minutes until it darkens to a deep brick red.

  3. Add the canned tomatoes, crushing each one in your fist as it goes in, along with the bay, thyme and stock. Simmer uncovered for 25 minutes, until it has thickened and the sharp tinned note has cooked away entirely.

  4. Remove the herbs and blend the base smooth, filling the jug no more than a third full and venting the lid under a folded towel. Pass it through a fine sieve, pressing hard, and set it aside.

  5. Stir the baking soda into the warm tomato base. It will foam up and subside within a few seconds. That reaction is carbon dioxide leaving as the soda neutralizes part of the tomato's citric and malic acid, and it is what makes the dairy safe.

  6. Now build the velouté in a clean, heavy pot. Melt the 40 g of butter over medium-low heat, scatter in the flour and whisk to a smooth paste. Cook it for 2–3 minutes, stirring, until it smells of biscuits and has gone a shade past pale — blond, not brown.

  7. Pour in the infused milk a ladleful at a time, whisking each addition to smoothness before the next. Adding it all at once is how lumps form; the flour needs to disperse into liquid gradually or it clumps and seals itself.

  8. Simmer the velouté for 5 minutes, whisking, until it coats the back of a spoon and holds a line drawn through it with a finger. Cooking it this long also removes the raw, pasty taste that under-cooked flour leaves behind.

  9. Add the warmed cream, then fold the tomato base into the velouté — this direction, not the other way round. Pouring dairy into a large volume of acid is exactly the condition under which it curdles; adding acid slowly into a starch-protected base is not.

  10. Season with salt, sugar, white pepper and nutmeg, and hold the pot below a simmer for 5 minutes to marry. It should be the color of terracotta and thick enough to coat a spoon without being sticky. Thin with a little stock if needed.

  11. Serve in warm bowls with a spiral of cream drawn across the surface and torn basil over the top. It wants something toasted and cheesy beside it, and for a century and a half it has always had it.

Cook’s notes

The technique
Milk curdles in tomato soup because casein micelles, which are stable in milk at pH 6.7, clump together as acidity approaches their isoelectric point around pH 4.6, and heat drives them together faster. There are three defenses and this recipe uses all of them. Baking soda raises the pH of the tomato before dairy ever meets it. The roux coats the proteins in gelatinized starch, which physically holds the micelles apart so they cannot aggregate. And the tomato goes into the dairy rather than the reverse, so the acid is diluted the whole way in. Get those three right and the pot can be reheated without fear, which is the real advantage of the classical route.
Make ahead
The tomato base alone keeps five days refrigerated and freezes for three months; make it in double quantity. The finished creamed soup holds three days but will not freeze — thawed roux-thickened dairy weeps and goes grainy. Reheat gently, stirring, and never let it boil; if it thickens on standing, let it down with warm milk rather than water so the ratio of starch to dairy stays right.
Troubleshooting
Grainy and separated — the tomato went in without soda, or the pot boiled after the dairy; blend it hard and it usually comes back. Pasty and dull — the roux was not cooked out. Lumpy — the milk went in too fast; push it through a sieve and whisk. Sharp and thin-tasting — under-seasoned; both the sugar and the salt matter more here than in a roasted version.
Variations
Cream of tomato with rice, an old hotel-menu standard, adds 60 g of long-grain rice to the base and blends it in for body with less flour. A tomato bisque proper is finished with a spoonful of sherry and thickened partly with rice as well. For a lighter bowl, replace the cream with evaporated milk, which is heat-stable and resists curdling better than fresh.
To serve and keep
Serve in warm, shallow bowls or in mugs. A toasted cheese sandwich or cheese straws is the standing partner. Oyster crackers scattered over are the American diner convention. Drink milk if you are five, or a glass of dry Riesling if you are not. Made in full within this recipe — Tomato Base, Blond Roux Velouté. Also listed in the Component Index at the back.

Where it comes from

Behind the smooth pink bowl of the American lunch counter sits a piece of French kitchen architecture. Antonin Carême organized the sauces of the early nineteenth century into families, and Auguste Escoffier tidied that system in Le Guide Culinaire of 1903 into the mother sauces still taught today, with a whole class of soups built on them: purées, veloutés thickened with a blond roux and white stock, and crèmes finished with milk or béchamel. American hotel and restaurant kitchens took the crème and velouté formulas wholesale, and by the 1920s a cream of something was on nearly every commercial menu in the country, tomato most of all. The diner inherited it from the hotel. Nineteenth-century American cookbooks were already printing the necessary trick — a pinch of soda into the tomato before the milk goes anywhere near it — because home cooks kept ruining the dish and writing in to complain. That trick and the roux together are the recipe. Roasting is the modern answer to tomato soup, and it is recipe 1; this is the older, more forgiving one.

Cream of Tomato: quick answers

How long does Cream of Tomato take?

About 55 minutes.

How many does this Cream of Tomato recipe make?

This recipe serves 4.

Where does Cream of Tomato come from?

Behind the smooth pink bowl of the American lunch counter sits a piece of French kitchen architecture. Antonin Carême organized the sauces of the early nineteenth century into families, and Auguste Escoffier tidied that system in Le Guide Culinaire of 1903 into the mother sauces still taught today, with a whole class of soups built on them: purées, veloutés thickened with a blond roux and white stock, and crèmes finished with milk or béchamel. American hotel and restaurant kitchens took the crème and velouté formulas wholesale, and by the 1920s a cream of something was on nearly every commercial menu in the country, tomato most of all. The diner inherited it from the hotel. Nineteenth-century American cookbooks were already printing the necessary trick — a pinch of soda into the tomato before the milk goes anywhere near it — because home cooks kept ruining the dish and writing in to complain. That trick and the roux together are the recipe. Roasting is the modern answer to tomato soup, and it is recipe 1; this is the older, more forgiving one.