# Hot and Sour Soup

White pepper for heat, black vinegar for sour, wood ear for texture.

Hot and Sour Soup comes from China · Sichuan and Beijing and appears in The Soup Atlas, in the chapter Broths &amp; Noodle Soups. It serves 4, takes about 50 minutes, and uses 19 ingredients and 10 steps.

- Volume: The Soup Atlas (Broths &amp; Noodle Soups)
- Origin: China · Sichuan and Beijing (36.75° N, 103.42° E)
- At a glance: Serves 4 · Stovetop · 50 minutes
- Source: https://www.atlasserie.com/recipes/soup/hot-and-sour-soup/

## Ingredients


### For the rehydrated dried goods
- 15 g (½ oz) dried wood ear mushrooms
- 15 g (½ oz) dried lily buds
- 4 dried shiitake mushrooms (15 g)
- 500 ml (2 cups) warm water, for soaking

### For the base
- 1.5 liters (6 cups) chicken stock, unsalted or low-sodium
- 200 g (7 oz) pork loin, in fine matchsticks
- 10 ml (2 tsp) Shaoxing wine and 1 tsp cornstarch, to marinate the pork
- 150 g (5 oz) bamboo shoots, in fine matchsticks
- 250 g (9 oz) firm tofu, in 5 mm strips
- 20 ml (4 tsp) light soy sauce
- 10 ml (2 tsp) dark soy sauce, for color
- 5 g (1 tsp) sugar

### For thickening and finishing
- 30 g (4 tbsp) cornstarch, whisked into 90 ml (6 tbsp) cold water
- 2 eggs, beaten and sieved
- 3 tsp ground white pepper, freshly ground if possible
- 60 ml (¼ cup) Chinkiang black vinegar
- 10 ml (2 tsp) toasted sesame oil
- 3 spring onions, sliced into fine rings
- 10 g (⅓ oz) coriander, chopped, optional

## Method

1. Soak the wood ear, lily buds and shiitake in the warm water for 30 minutes, until the wood ear has swelled to five times its size and turned gelatinous. Use dried lily buds only — fresh daylily buds contain compounds that upset the stomach — and do not leave any of them soaking at room temperature for hours; refrigerate if you need longer.
2. Drain, keeping the soaking liquid, and strain it through muslin to catch the grit; it is worth as much as stock. Trim the woody knots from the wood ear and slice it into ribbons. Pinch the hard tip off each lily bud and tie or halve the rest. Slice the shiitake thin.
3. Toss the pork matchsticks with the wine and teaspoon of cornstarch and leave for 10 minutes. The starch coating sets on contact with hot liquid and keeps lean pork tender in a soup that will simmer and then be thickened.
4. Bring the stock and the strained soaking liquid to a simmer with the shiitake, wood ear, lily buds and bamboo shoots and cook for 8 minutes, so the dried goods give back some of what the water took out of them.
5. Slide in the pork, separating the strands, and cook for 2 minutes until the pieces turn opaque. Add the tofu, both soy sauces and the sugar, and warm through for 3 minutes without stirring hard enough to break the strips.
6. Grind in the white pepper — start with 2 teaspoons and hold the rest back. This is the heat of the dish, and it works differently from chile: it blooms in hot liquid, builds over a minute, and settles at the back of the throat rather than on the front of the tongue.
7. Whisk the cornstarch slurry again, since it settles within minutes, and stir it into the simmering soup in a steady stream. Cook for 2 minutes until the soup turns glossy and coats the back of a spoon; it should be thick enough to hold the egg, not thick enough to mound.
8. Drop the heat until the surface barely moves. Stir a slow whirlpool and pour the sieved egg in a thin stream from a height, working it across the pot, then stop stirring and leave it undisturbed for ten seconds while the ribbons set.
9. Take the pot off the heat and only now add the black vinegar. Acetic acid is volatile and boils off within seconds, taking the malty top notes with it and leaving a flat, faintly bitter edge; a soup that tastes vinegary in the pan and dull in the bowl was boiled after the vinegar went in.
10. Taste and push it toward the two poles. It should be sour first, then hot, with the savory base underneath and no sweetness worth naming. Adjust with vinegar and pepper rather than salt. Stir in the sesame oil, ladle into bowls and scatter with spring onion and coriander.

## Cook's notes

- **The technique:** Both defining flavors are fragile in the same way and for different reasons. White pepper's piperine and its aromatic oils dull with long cooking, so it goes in near the end and gets a second grind at the table if wanted; black vinegar's acetic acid and its aged, malty esters evaporate at a simmer, so it goes in with the heat off entirely. Add both early and you get a soup that is technically hot and sour and tastes of neither. The starch matters too: it holds the egg in suspension and gives the pepper something to cling to on the tongue.
- **Make ahead:** The soaked dried goods keep two days refrigerated in fresh water. The base — stock, mushrooms, bamboo, pork and tofu — can be made a day ahead and reheats well. Thicken, ribbon the egg and add the vinegar only when you serve. A fully finished soup thins overnight as the starch relaxes and loses its sourness, and reheating it demands a fresh splash of vinegar and pepper.
- **Troubleshooting:** Thin and watery after standing — the starch was under-cooked or the soup was reheated; whisk in a fresh slurry and simmer two minutes. Sour but not hot — not enough pepper, and chile will not stand in for it. Flat despite plenty of vinegar — it went in over the heat. Egg in lumps — the pot was boiling when it was poured.
- **Variations:** Sichuan versions run leaner and hotter, sometimes with cubes of set duck blood and no thickener to speak of. Beijing restaurant style is the thick, egg-ribboned bowl most people recognize. Take the pork out and the soup is entirely vegetarian, and it loses little. American takeout versions add chile oil, dark soy and more sugar, which shifts it toward a third thing altogether.
- **To serve and keep:** Serve in small bowls at the start of a meal, with a spoon and a bottle of black vinegar on the table for those who want it sharper. It goes with dumplings and fried things, whose fat it cuts. Hot tea; the vinegar and pepper make short work of wine. Made in full within this recipe — Rehydrated Wood Ear and Lily Buds, Pork and Bamboo Base, Vinegar and Pepper Finish. Also listed in the Component Index at the back.

## Origins

Suānlà tāng is claimed by two kitchens and no dated attribution survives for either. The Sichuan account runs it back to a peasant soup of the province's damp winters, sharpened with vinegar and white pepper; the Beijing version descends from the Shandong-trained restaurant cooks who dominated the capital's trade, and it is thicker with starch, built on tofu, wood ear, lily buds and a ribbon of egg. Both are real, both are eaten in both cities, and menus draw the line more confidently than cooks do. What distinguishes the dish from every other soup in this chapter is that its two defining sensations come from a spice and an acid rather than from a chile: white pepper delivers a dry, penetrating heat that sits at the back of the throat, and Chinkiang black vinegar, brewed from glutinous rice and aged, gives a malty sourness closer to balsamic than to anything sharp. Henan's peppery breakfast soup, hulatang, is a separate dish often confused with this one abroad.
