# Pain au Levain

French naturally leavened bread: aromatic, faintly acid, never sharp.

Pain au Levain comes from France · Levain Naturel and appears in The Bread Atlas, in the chapter Artisan &amp; Sourdough. It makes 1 boule, takes about 24 hours, and uses 10 ingredients and 11 steps.

- Volume: The Bread Atlas (Artisan &amp; Sourdough)
- Origin: France · Levain Naturel (46.56° N, 2.35° E)
- At a glance: Makes 1 boule · Oven 245°C / 470°F · 24 hours
- Source: https://www.atlasserie.com/recipes/bread/pain-au-levain/

## Ingredients


### Stiff Levain (levain de tout point)
- 20 g (1 tbsp) ripe sourdough starter — see the build in recipe 16 4%
- 75 g (⅝ cup) strong white bread flour 15%
- 25 g (3½ tbsp) whole rye flour 5%
- 60 g (¼ cup) water at 26°C 12%

### The Dough
- 350 g (2⅘ cups) French T65 or strong white bread flour 70%
- 50 g (6 tbsp) whole rye flour 10%
- 300 g (1¼ cups) water at 30°C 60%
- 10 g (1¾ tsp) fine sea salt 2%

### For Shaping and Baking
- 40 g (⅓ cup) rice flour and white flour mixed, for the banneton 8%
- 250 ml boiling water, for the steam tray

## Method

1. Refresh the starter twice in the twelve hours before you build, at eight-hour intervals, keeping it at 24–26°C. Frequent feeding is the single practice that keeps a levain mild: a culture that is never allowed to go hungry never has the chance to accumulate acid.
2. Build the stiff levain 8–10 hours ahead. Dissolve the starter in the water at 26°C, then knead in the white and rye flours to a firm ball, barely tacky. Cover and hold at 22°C.
3. Use it as soon as it has doubled and the surface has domed and split — a stiff levain shows readiness by cracking rather than by bubbling — and no later. Smell it: cream, hazelnut and a little cider is right, vinegar is late.
4. Mix both dough flours with the water at 30°C and autolyse 40 minutes. Then tear in the levain, squeeze it through until no lumps of it remain, add the salt, and work the dough 4–5 minutes to a smooth mass at 25–26°C.
5. Bulk ferment 4 hours at 26°C, folding at 40, 80 and 120 minutes. Warm and reasonably brisk is deliberate: warmth favors lactic acid over acetic, and a bulk that is short enough to keep the total acid low is what separates this loaf from a San Francisco one.
6. End the bulk at a rise of about 60%, with a domed, gassy surface and a smell that is still sweet. This dough should never smell sharp at any point. If it does, the levain went in over-ripe or the kitchen ran hot.
7. Preshape into a round, rest 25 minutes, then shape a firm boule and set it seam up in a floured banneton. The 15% rye makes the dough a little stickier than a white one; use a scraper and a light dusting rather than more flour on the bench.
8. Retard 8–10 hours at 4°C — shorter than the boule of recipe 16, on purpose. A long cold night builds acidity, and the point of this loaf is to arrive at the oven aromatic and only just acid.
9. Heat the oven to 245°C / 470°F for 45 minutes with a stone on the middle shelf and a heavy tray on the floor. Turn the loaf onto parchment and score it with a cross or two long crescent cuts, 1 cm deep, blade at 30°.
10. Load, pour boiling water into the tray, and bake 20 minutes. Vent the oven, drop to 220°C / 430°F, and bake 20 minutes more, to a deep russet crust and 98°C inside. The rye in the dough will take the crust darker than a white loaf at the same setting.
11. Cool 3 hours before cutting. The crumb should be cream-colored and irregularly open, the smell nutty and lactic, and the taste round rather than sour — closer to yogurt and hazelnut than to vinegar. If it tastes tangy, treat that as a fault to correct.

## Cook's notes

- **To serve and keep:** The everyday bread of a French table where the baguette is the everyday bread of the street: cut in generous slices for cheese, charcuterie and soup, and rubbed with garlic and oil when stale. Store cut side down on a board and expect it to be better tomorrow.

## Origins

France defines this bread in law. The décret pain of 13 September 1993 states what a levain is — a dough of wheat or rye flour, water and optionally salt, carrying a spontaneous acidifying fermentation and capable of raising a dough — and sets two numbers for the bread made from it: the crumb must reach a pH of 4.3 or below, and no more than 0.2% baker's yeast may be added at the final mixing. A loaf that meets those conditions may be sold as pain au levain and one that does not may not. Behind the regulation sits an older working vocabulary. A French bakery keeps a levain chef, the mother culture, and builds it forward in stages — levain de première, levain de tout point — refreshing at each step so that the leaven going into the dough is young, vigorous and only mildly acid. The result is a bread with a great deal of aroma and comparatively little sourness, and that balance, rather than any tang, is what French bakers mean by levain.
