# Jewish Rye

Caraway-flecked deli rye with a shining crust, cut thin for pastrami.

Jewish Rye comes from Eastern Europe · The New York Deli and appears in The Bread Atlas, in the chapter Breads Around the World. It makes 1 loaf, takes about 20 hours, and uses 13 ingredients and 11 steps.

- Volume: The Bread Atlas (Breads Around the World)
- Origin: Eastern Europe · The New York Deli (50.00° N, 25.00° E)
- At a glance: Makes 1 loaf · Oven 230°C / 450°F · 20 hours with the sour
- Source: https://www.atlasserie.com/recipes/bread/jewish-rye/

## Ingredients


### Rye Sour — Three Builds
- Build 1, 8 hours: 20 g mature rye starter, 40 g (⅓ cup) medium rye flour, 40 g water at 28°C 8% flour
- Build 2, 6 hours: add 30 g (¼ cup) medium rye flour and 30 g water at 28°C 6% flour
- Build 3, 4 hours: add 30 g (¼ cup) medium rye flour and 30 g water at 28°C 6% flour

### Altus — Old Bread Soaker
- 50 g (2 slices) stale rye bread, crusts included, torn small 10%
- 150 g (⅔ cup) cold water, to cover 30%

### The Dough
- 340 g (2¾ cups) first clear flour — strong bread flour with 30 g wholemeal wheat stirred in is the nearest substitute 68%
- 60 g (½ cup) medium rye flour 12%
- 225 g (1 cup less 1 tbsp) water at 20°C 45%
- 10 g (1¾ tsp) fine sea salt 2%
- 5 g (2 tsp) whole caraway seed 1%
- 2 g (1 tsp) caraway seed, finely ground 0.4%
- 3 g (1 tsp) instant yeast 0.6%
- Cornmeal or rye flour for the peel

## Method

1. Begin the sour the morning before. Mix build 1 and leave 8 hours at 26°C; feed build 2 into it and leave 6 hours; feed build 3 and leave 4 hours. Three staged builds give a sour that is fully active but only moderately acidic; a single long build turns sharp and slows the dough.
2. The finished sour should be domed, riddled with bubbles and smelling of sour cream and green apple. If it smells of solvent it has gone too far; refresh it once more with 30 g each of rye and water and give it 3 hours.
3. Make the altus alongside build 3. Tear the stale rye into a bowl, cover with cold water and leave 3 hours until fully softened, then squeeze it out hard by the handful. You want about 60 g of damp pulp and no free water at all.
4. Altus is the deli baker's economy that became a technique. The soaked bread contributes pre-gelatinized starch that holds moisture, plus the caramelized flavor already built into the old crust, giving a depth no single-day dough reaches.
5. Mix the sour, the squeezed altus, both flours, the water at 20°C, the yeast and both forms of caraway. Rest 20 minutes, then add the salt and mix 6 minutes on low. Rye limits how far this can be pushed: cohesive and tacky, not fully elastic. Target 26°C.
6. Grind part of the caraway and leave the rest whole. Ground seed distributes its oils through the crumb; whole seed gives the pop between the teeth. Use only whole seed and the loaf tastes of nothing between the pops.
7. Bulk ferment 60–75 minutes at 26°C with one gentle fold at 35 minutes. Look for a rise of about half and a surface gone puffy and slightly slack. Rye sours move faster than wheat levains and overshoot without warning.
8. Shape a tight oval: flatten, fold and seal in thirds, then roll and stretch to about 28 cm, sealing the seam firmly and tapering the ends. Rye dough tears rather than stretches, so use wet hands and work with decision rather than force.
9. Prove seam-side up in a rye-floured oval basket, 45–60 minutes at 26°C. Rye underproves invisibly and overproves catastrophically; go by a finger dent filling back three-quarters, and by fine cracks opening across the flour on the surface.
10. Heat the oven to 230°C / 450°F with a stone and steam tray for 45 minutes. Turn the loaf out and score five or six shallow diagonals, shallower than you would cut a wheat loaf, since rye lacks the strength to hold a deep opening.
11. Bake 15 minutes with heavy steam, then vent, drop to 200°C / 400°F and bake 30–35 minutes more to an internal 96°C. For the deli shine, brush with cornstarch glaze — 5 g cornstarch cooked in 100 g water — as it leaves the oven. Cool at least 6 hours, ideally overnight, before slicing thin.

## Cook's notes

- **To serve and keep:** Sliced thin and piled with hot pastrami, mustard and a sour pickle, or with corned beef and coleslaw. Also the base for chopped liver and a proper egg salad. Store cut-side down in paper inside a cloth; refrigeration stales rye faster than any other treatment.

## Origins

The rye breads that Jewish bakers brought out of Poland, Lithuania and Ukraine in the migration of 1880–1920 were reworked almost immediately by what they found in New York. American wheat was strong and abundant, and first clear flour — the high-ash stream left after the patent flour is drawn off — was cheap and gave a rye dough both strength and a distinctive tang. The proportions inverted: where the old-country loaf might be mostly rye, the deli loaf settled at roughly a third, wheat-supported, lighter and sliceable. The bakers kept the rye sour, refreshed in stages across a day, and kept caraway. They kept altus too, the Yiddish practice of soaking yesterday's unsold rye and mixing it back into today's dough. The corn rye of the delicatessen has no corn in it at all — korn is Yiddish for rye grain — and is no more than the sour loaf given a hard steam bake for a glossy crust. It is the platform for pastrami, sliced thin, and it is not the same bread as its German ancestors.
